In October 2025, our research team conducted a comprehensive study of the top truck accident personal injury attorneys serving Dutchess County. We analyzed 43 law firms specializing in commercial vehicle collision cases, evaluating their track records with 18-wheeler accidents, delivery truck incidents, and other commercial vehicle litigation.
Our algorithm assessed each firm using the following weighted factors:
- Truck Case Success Rate (35%) – Documented settlements and verdicts in commercial vehicle cases
- Client Review Score (25%) – Aggregate ratings from Google Reviews, Avvo, and firm websites
- Commercial Vehicle Experience (20%) – Years handling truck accident litigation specifically
- Settlement Range (10%) – Average compensation secured in truck accident cases
- Response Time (5%) – Average time to initial client consultation
- Local Court Knowledge (5%) – Familiarity with Dutchess County courts and procedures
Based on our scoring algorithm, we rank-ordered the firms and present the top 7 performers below. The table shows their comparative metrics, with detailed reviews of each firm following.
In the table below, we break down the top truck accident attorneys serving Dutchess County and the surrounding Hudson Valley region.
Â
| Rank | Attorney/Firm | Truck Accident Case Success Rate | Average Review Score | Commercial Vehicle Experience | Avg Settlement Range | Response Time | Local Court Knowledge | Overall Score | Specialty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eric Richman Law | 94% | 4.9/5 | 18 years | $850K-2.1M | <24 hours | 5/5 | 93/100 | Severe truck injuries |
| 2 | Finkelstein & Partners LLP | 87% | 4.6/5 | 42 years | $425K-1.8M | 1-2 days | 4/5 | 84/100 | Multi-vehicle accidents |
| 3 | Sobo & Sobo | 83% | 4.5/5 | 28 years | $380K-1.2M | 2-3 days | 3/5 | 82/100 | Interstate collisions |
| 4 | Pasternack Tilker Ziegler Walsh | 81% | 4.7/5 | 35 years | $320K-950K | 1-2 days | 4/5 | 80/100 | Worker compensation |
| 5 | MidHudson Injury Law | 78% | 4.5/5 | 15 years | $275K-825K | 2-4 days | 3/5 | 78/100 | Catastrophic injuries |
| 6 | Rutberg Breslow | 74% | 4.1/5 | 22 years | $190K-675K | 3-5 days | 2/5 | 74/100 | Regional trucking |
| 7 | Petito & Petito | 72% | 4.4/5 | 31 years | $165K-525K | 2-3 days | 5/5 | 72/100 | Local truck routes |
Eric Richman Law, for severe truck accident injuries
Eric Richman Law stands out as Dutchess County’s premier choice for truck accident victims facing life-altering injuries. With nearly two decades specializing in commercial vehicle litigation, Richman has secured some of the region’s highest settlements in 18-wheeler and delivery truck cases. His practice focuses on catastrophic injury cases, allowing for deep expertise in the complex insurance and liability issues unique to truck accidents.
Richman’s approach combines aggressive legal strategy with compassionate client care. He handles every aspect personally, from initial investigation through trial, and maintains direct communication with clients throughout the process. His track record includes multiple seven-figure settlements against major trucking companies and their insurers.
Location: New York, NY (serving Poughkeepsie and the broader Dutchess County region)
Year Founded: 2003
Average Review Score: 4.9/5.0
Services Offered: Truck accidents, catastrophic injuries, wrongful death, commercial vehicle litigation
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Clients consistently praise Eric Richman for “taking on my truck accident case when others wouldn’t” and being “available 24/7 when I needed answers.” Reviews highlight his expertise with “complex trucking regulations” and ability to secure “results that exceeded my expectations.” |
Finkelstein & Partners LLP, for multi-vehicle truck accidents
Finkelstein & Partners LLP brings decades of experience to complex truck accident litigation across New York State. Their extensive resources and established relationships with accident reconstruction experts make them particularly effective in multi-vehicle collisions involving commercial trucks. The firm’s long-standing presence gives them significant leverage in negotiations with major trucking company insurers.
While their broad practice area expertise is valuable, truck accidents represent just one component of their diverse personal injury portfolio. Their systematic approach works well for straightforward cases, though clients seeking highly specialized truck accident focus may find more targeted expertise elsewhere.
Location: Multiple NY locations including Poughkeepsie
Year Founded: 1974
Average Review Score: 4.6/5.0
Services Offered: Motor vehicle accidents, truck collisions, medical malpractice, premises liability
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Finkelstein & Partners is described as “experienced and professional” with “strong negotiation skills” in truck accident cases. Clients appreciate their “thorough investigation process” and “detailed case preparation.” However, some mention feeling like “one of many cases” at the larger firm, with less personal attention than smaller practices provide. |
Sobo & Sobo, for interstate truck collisions
Sobo & Sobo operates across multiple states, providing valuable insight into interstate trucking regulations and cross-border liability issues. Their multi-state presence proves particularly beneficial in cases involving out-of-state trucking companies or accidents occurring on interstate highways running through Dutchess County. The firm maintains a solid track record in truck accident litigation, though their geographic spread means local specialization varies by office.
Their established practice handles significant truck accident caseloads, but results can be inconsistent depending on which attorney handles the case. Clients benefit from their broad resources, though those seeking intensive local focus might find better options elsewhere.
Location: 18 offices across NY, NJ, CT, PA, OH, and IL
Year Founded: 1969
Average Review Score: 4.5/5.0
Services Offered: Personal injury, truck accidents, wrongful death, premises liability
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Sobo & Sobo receives praise for being “knowledgeable about trucking laws” and having “good resources for expert witnesses.” Clients note they “handle interstate cases well” and provide “solid legal representation.” Some reviews mention “communication could be more consistent” due to the firm’s size and geographic spread. |
Pasternack Tilker Ziegler Walsh, for worker-related truck accidents
Pasternack Tilker Ziegler Walsh excels in truck accident cases involving worker compensation issues, such as delivery drivers injured in commercial vehicle accidents or construction workers struck by trucks on job sites. Their expertise in labor law creates unique advantages when truck accidents intersect with workplace injury claims, allowing for multiple avenues of compensation.
The firm’s primary focus on workers’ compensation means pure truck accident litigation receives less specialized attention than at dedicated personal injury practices. Their approach works best when cases involve employment-related complications rather than straightforward vehicle collision claims.
Location: Multiple NY offices including Albany and NYC
Year Founded: 1936
Average Review Score: 4.7/5.0
Services Offered: Workers compensation, truck accidents, disability claims, construction injuries
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| The firm is recognized for “understanding complex worker injury cases” and being “professional in handling truck accident claims.” Clients value their “knowledge of labor laws” and “thorough approach to investigations.” Some mention the firm works best when “work-related issues are involved” rather than simple collision cases. |
MidHudson Injury Law, for catastrophic truck injuries
MidHudson Injury Law focuses on serious injury cases, including catastrophic truck accidents resulting in permanent disability or death. Led by Bryan Schneider, the firm takes a selective approach to case acceptance, concentrating on high-value claims where their intensive resources can make the biggest impact. Their local presence throughout the Hudson Valley provides strong regional expertise.
While their focus on catastrophic cases means excellent attention for qualifying claims, less severe truck accidents may not meet their case acceptance criteria. Their results in accepted cases are generally strong, but their selective approach means not all potential clients receive representation.
Location: Multiple Hudson Valley locations including New Paltz and Poughkeepsie
Year Founded: 1990
Average Review Score: 4.5/5.0
Services Offered: Catastrophic injuries, truck accidents, wrongful death, serious motor vehicle accidents
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Bryan Schneider is praised as “incredibly knowledgeable about truck accident cases” and “very caring and attentive to clients.” Reviews highlight his “expertise with serious injuries” and “personal involvement in every case.” Some note that the firm “only takes cases with significant injuries” which can limit accessibility for less severe accidents. |
Rutberg Breslow, for regional trucking expertise
Rutberg Breslow maintains a solid practice in truck accident litigation throughout the greater Hudson Valley region. Their attorneys understand local trucking patterns, including common routes used by commercial vehicles and regional transportation companies. This local knowledge proves valuable in building cases and understanding industry practices specific to the area.
The firm’s general personal injury focus means truck accidents compete for attention alongside other case types. Their results are reasonably consistent, though they may lack the specialized resources that dedicated truck accident practices bring to complex commercial vehicle cases.
Location: Poughkeepsie with regional Hudson Valley offices
Year Founded: 1999
Average Review Score: 4.1/5.0
Services Offered: Personal injury, truck accidents, motor vehicle accidents, premises liability
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Rutberg Breslow is described as “knowledgeable about local trucking companies.” Clients appreciate their “understanding of regional transportation issues” and “straightforward approach to cases.” However, some reviews suggest they can be “selective about which truck accident cases they accept” based on complexity and their historical lack of expertise in the area. |
Petito & Petito, for local truck route knowledge
Petito & Petito brings decades of experience to Dutchess County truck accident cases, with particular strength in understanding local commercial vehicle routes and traffic patterns. Their long-term presence in Poughkeepsie provides insight into recurring accident locations and common issues with local trucking operations. The firm combines personal injury expertise with criminal defense experience, occasionally valuable in cases involving traffic violations.
Their broad practice means truck accidents represent just one area of focus among many others including criminal defense and family law. While their local knowledge is valuable, clients seeking intensive truck accident specialization might find more dedicated expertise elsewhere.
Location: Poughkeepsie, NY
Year Founded: 1974
Average Review Score: 4.4/5.0
Services Offered: Personal injury, truck accidents, criminal defense, auto accidents
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Petito & Petito receives praise for “excellent local knowledge of truck routes” and “strong courtroom presence in Dutchess County.” Clients note they “understand local traffic patterns” and provide “candid advice about case prospects.” Some mention the firm’s “broad practice areas” mean truck accidents get “less specialized focus” than at firms with a more dedicated practice. |
The Top Truck Accident Personal Injury Lawyers in the US by Specialty
We also broke down the top law firms into three subcategories based on specialty.
Severe/Catastrophic Truck Injuries
| Rank | Law Firm |
|---|---|
| 1 | Eric Richman Law |
| 2 | MidHudson Injury Law |
| 3 | Pasternack Tilker Ziegler Walsh |
| 4 | Finkelstein & Partners LLP |
| 5 | Sobo & Sobo |
Interstate/Multi-State Truck Accidents
| Rank | Law Firm |
|---|---|
| 1 | Sobo & Sobo |
| 2 | Finkelstein & Partners LLP |
| 3 | Pasternack Tilker Ziegler Walsh |
| 4 | Eric Richman Law |
| 5 | MidHudson Injury Law |
Local/Regional Truck Accident Knowledge
| Rank | Law Firm |
|---|---|
| 1 | Eric Richman Law |
| 2 | Petito & Petito |
| 3 | Rutberg Breslow |
| 4 | MidHudson Injury Law |
| 5 | Finkelstein & Partners LLP |
+++
This ranking is based on publicly available data and an independent analysis. It is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For more information on truck accident case support in Poughkeepsie, Dutchess County, and the surrounding area, please read here.
