Top Car Accident Personal Injury Lawyers in Manhattan: 2026 Rankings

In 2026, our research team conducted a comprehensive study of car accident personal injury lawyers serving Manhattan. We analyzed 60 different attorneys and law firms, focusing exclusively on those with demonstrable experience representing car accident victims in Manhattan. We narrowed that list down to the top eight selections using our proprietary ranking algorithm. The algorithm is made up of the following factors:

• Car Accident Case Results (30%): Documented verdicts and settlements in car accident cases. Sourced from firm websites, press releases, legal databases, and publicly available court records.
• Attorney Experience & Credentials (25%): Total years practicing personal injury law, educational background, bar admissions, and professional recognition. Verified through firm websites, attorney biographies, state bar records, and professional profiles.
• Client Accessibility (20%): Direct attorney access, personalized service, and communication responsiveness. Evaluated through client testimonials, service descriptions, and stated communication policies.
• Average Review Score (15%): Combined Google and Avvo ratings out of 5.0. Collected from Google Business profiles, Avvo.com, and other publicly available review platforms.
• Trial Readiness (10%): Proven willingness to take car accident cases to trial. Assessed through publicly available verdicts, case histories, and attorney profiles.

Our algorithm rank-ordered attorneys based on these weighted criteria. The table below presents the top eight performers, with detailed reviews following each listing.

Top Car Accident Personal Injury Lawyers in Manhattan

Top Car Accident Personal Injury Lawyers in Manhattan: Descriptions & Reviews

1. Law Offices of Eric Richman

Eric Richman has spent over two decades aggressively fighting for car accident victims across Manhattan and all five boroughs of New York City. His practice gives injured clients something rare: 24/7 direct access to an attorney, with no intake coordinators or paralegals standing between you and your legal team when it matters most. He handles the full spectrum of car accident cases, from rear-end collisions and intersection crashes to multi-vehicle pileups, and is well-versed in New York’s no-fault insurance system and serious injury threshold requirements.

• Car Accident Case Results: Multiple six and seven-figure settlements for car accident victims across Manhattan and all five boroughs.
• Attorney Experience & Credentials: 25+ years exclusively PI. Penn Law JD, summa cum laude, Phi Beta Kappa. Admitted in New York and New Jersey.
• Client Accessibility: Direct cell phone access to Eric or his team, 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
• Average Review Score: 4.9/5.0 across Google and Avvo. 200+ verified five-star reviews.
• Trial Readiness: Will take cases to trial. Does not settle unless it serves the client’s best interest.

2. Jaroslawicz & Jaros

Jaroslawicz & Jaros has practiced personal injury law in Manhattan for over four decades, with partners remaining directly involved in case handling throughout. The firm represents car accident victims across a range of collision types and emphasizes early case investigation and damage documentation, refusing to accept insurance companies’ initial low settlement offers.

• Car Accident Case Results: Multi-million dollar PI track record in vehicle collision and serious injury cases across New York City.
• Attorney Experience & Credentials: Founded in 1980. 40+ years of NYC personal injury experience.
• Client Accessibility: Partner involvement throughout the case. Selective intake; not all matters are accepted.
• Average Review Score: 4.6/5.0 across publicly available platforms.
• Trial Readiness: Active litigation practice in car accident and vehicle collision cases.

3. Gersowitz Libo & Korek

Since 1984, Gersowitz Libo & Korek has recovered over $1 billion for injured New Yorkers, with car accidents forming a significant portion of their practice. Partners Edward Gersowitz, Andrew Libo, and Jeff Korek bring decades of combined experience to Manhattan car accident cases, from intersection crashes to catastrophic multi-vehicle collisions.

• Car Accident Case Results: $1 billion+ recovered over 40 years. Car accidents form a core part of the firm’s practice.
• Attorney Experience & Credentials: Founded 1984. Super Lawyers and Best Lawyers recognized.
• Client Accessibility: Selective caseload. Personal attention for accepted clients. Limited defined after-hours access.
• Average Review Score: 4.7/5.0 across publicly available platforms.
• Trial Readiness: Proven record in complex, multi-party vehicle collision litigation.

4. Flanzig & Flanzig

Flanzig & Flanzig has represented car accident victims in Manhattan for decades, with particular expertise in cases involving pedestrians, cyclists, and vulnerable road users injured in collisions. The firm has secured multimillion-dollar recoveries for victims struck by turning vehicles and distracted drivers, and is well versed in navigating New York’s no-fault insurance laws and uninsured motorist coverage issues.

• Car Accident Case Results: Multimillion-dollar recoveries in collision cases. Specialized experience with vulnerable road user claims.
• Attorney Experience & Credentials: Founded 1956. Decades of experience in NYC vehicle collision and traffic accident law.
• Client Accessibility: Standard intake process. Less clearly defined after-hours attorney access.
• Average Review Score: 4.7/5.0 across publicly available platforms.
• Trial Readiness: Aggressive trial representation with documented history in collision cases.

5. Hecht, Kleeger & Damashek

Founded by attorneys who trained at some of New York City’s largest law firms, Hecht, Kleeger & Damashek brings institutional-level legal strategy to cases handled at a partner-direct level. Located in Midtown Manhattan, the firm has recovered over $825 million for injured clients across all five boroughs, including car accident victims of all collision types.

• Car Accident Case Results: $825 million+ recovered across New York City’s five boroughs.
• Attorney Experience & Credentials: Founded in 1999. Partners trained at NYC’s largest law firms.
• Client Accessibility: Partner-driven boutique. Clients work directly with senior attorneys throughout.
• Average Review Score: 4.7/5.0 across publicly available platforms.
• Trial Readiness: Active five-borough trial record with big-firm courtroom strategy.

6. Raphaelson & Levine

Since 1992, Raphaelson & Levine has recovered over $1 billion for New York injury victims, with car accidents representing a significant portion of their practice. Partners Howard Raphaelson and Andrew Levine combine aggressive advocacy with deep knowledge of motor vehicle law, and their multilingual team serves a diverse cross-section of Manhattan car accident victims.

• Car Accident Case Results: $1 billion+ recovered since 1992 across motor vehicle and personal injury cases.
• Attorney Experience & Credentials: Founded 1992. 30+ years NYC PI experience. Multilingual team.
• Client Accessibility: Larger team structure. Clients may work with multiple attorneys throughout their case.
• Average Review Score: 4.6/5.0 across publicly available platforms.
• Trial Readiness: Aggressive litigation history across a broad range of car accident case types.

7. Sullivan Papain Block McGrath Coffinas & Cannavo

Sullivan Papain Block McGrath Coffinas & Cannavo is one of the oldest and most established personal injury firms in New York City, with a history dating back to 1929. The firm has extensive experience in transportation accident cases, including car accidents, and has handled some of the most complex and high-profile PI litigation in New York City history.

• Car Accident Case Results: Extensive NYC transportation accident litigation record spanning nearly a century of practice.
• Attorney Experience & Credentials: Founded 1929. One of New York City’s oldest and most established PI firms.
• Client Accessibility: Large institutional firm. Intake is typically staff-mediated with less direct partner access.
• Average Review Score: 4.6/5.0 across publicly available platforms.
• Trial Readiness: Significant transportation litigation trial record across decades of NYC courtroom practice.

8. Cellino Law

Cellino Law is a large regional personal injury firm with offices across New York State, including New York City, handling a high volume of auto accident cases for injury victims. The firm’s scale allows it to handle significant litigation demands across a wide range of vehicle collision claims, though its high-volume model and regional structure mean the client experience differs considerably from that of Manhattan boutique practices.

• Car Accident Case Results: High-volume auto accident practice with a substantial statewide case history.
• Attorney Experience & Credentials: Regional firm with NYC offices. Large team with experience across auto accident case types.
• Client Accessibility: High-volume practice. Clients typically work with associates or support staff rather than named partners.
• Average Review Score: 4.4/5.0 across publicly available platforms.
• Trial Readiness: Active auto accident trial practice across New York State.

Best Car Accident Lawyers in Manhattan for Direct Attorney Access

Best Car Accident Lawyers in Manhattan by Established Track Record

To request a copy of this list in PDF format, contact us here.