Our research team conducted a comprehensive analysis of top pedestrian accident attorneys covering Poughkeepsie and the surrounding area from January 2025 to September 2025.
We evaluated 32 law firms that help clients who were on foot and were victims of a collision between a vehicle (such as a car, truck, or motorcycle) or suffered from a fall that occurred due to unsafe road conditions.
A weighted scoring system was used to rank the firms who truly serve pedestrian victims best in Poughkeepsie. We highlighted the top 6 firms based on our analysis.
How We Ranked the Pedestrian Accident Lawyers in Poughkeepsie:
- Case Success Rate (30 points) – Reported outcomes based on publicly available case outcomes and reported settlements via public records and law firm websites
- Client Review Score (30 points) – Data collected from publicly available sources including Avvo, Google Reviews, and firm websites (January–September 2025)
- Review Volume (10 points) – Number of Reviews Available from publicly available sources including Avvo, Google Reviews, and firm websites (January–September 2025)
- Years of Experience (20 points) – Total years practicing in Poughkeepsie and Dutchess County broadly
- Related Accident Cases (10 points) – How many pedestrian cases the firm has tried in the Poughkeepsie area, based on publicly available case outcomes and reported settlements via public records and law firm websites.
Poughkeepsie’s Top Pedestrian Accident Attorneys
| Rank | Attorney/Firm | Case Success Rate | Average Review Score | Years of Experience | Related Accident Cases | Total Reviews | Total Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Eric Richman Law | 96% | 4.9/5 | 22 | 37 | 152+ | 93/100 |
| 2 | Ellis Law | 91% | 4.5/5 | 33 | 29 | 8+ | 82/100 |
| 3 | Petito & Petito | 78% | 4.7/5 | 51 | 8 | 5+ | 67/100 |
| 4 | Rinaldi Law | 73% | 3.9/5 | 40 | 7 | 15+ | 49/100 |
| 5 | Rutberg Breslow | 76% | 4.1/5 | 26 | 14 | 13+ | 47/100 |
| 6 | MidHudson Injury Law | 71% | 4.8/5 | 26 | 8 | 38+ | 45/100 |
Attorney Profiles: Top Poughkeepsie Pedestrian Accident Law Firms
Eric Richman Law, for pedestrian accident expertise
Eric Richman Law has built a reputation as one of the Hudson Valley’s go-to firms for pedestrian accident victims. With over two decades of experience, Richman has tried more pedestrian cases than many of his peers combined, giving him a depth of knowledge in navigating complex liability and insurance disputes. His consistent presence and strong case results in Poughkeepsie and Dutchess County have made him a trusted name locally.
Location: New York, NY
Year Established: 2003
Services Offered: Pedestrian accidents, crosswalk accidents, traffic collisions, wrongful death
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Eric Richman Law has been described as “honest, hardworking, dedicated” and attorneys are praised as “genuine, caring, real human” and “detail oriented.” Clients highlight his “expertise, compassion, touch of genius,” noting that he provides personal attention, explains every step, and approaches cases with both strategic judgment and empathy. |
Ellis Law, for handling tough cases with precision
Ellis Law is a cornerstone firm for clients facing life-altering injuries, particularly spinal cord, brain, and major construction accident cases. While they have handled over 25 pedestrian accident cases, the firm’s reputation is strongest in catastrophic injury litigation, combining large-firm resources with multiple offices across NYC, Albany, Fishkill, and Poughkeepsie. Some clients find their website confusing to navigate, but this minor friction can be outweighed by their courtroom experience and thorough case preparation.
Location: Poughkeepsie (with offices in NYC, Albany, and Fishkill)
Year Established: 1982
Services Offered: Spinal cord injuries, brain injuries, pedestrian accidents, construction accidents
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Ellis Law has been reviewed as “friendly” and “great people,” with clients noting the team was “helpful in pointing me in the right direction.” While reviews are shorter, they emphasize approachable staff, professionalism, and guidance through complicated cases. |
Petito & Petito, for seasoned courtroom advocacy
Petito & Petito has been a mainstay in Poughkeepsie for over 50 years, combining personal injury and criminal defense expertise. Their pedestrian accident portfolio is limited, but clients value the firm’s aggressive approach and long-standing presence in the community.
Location: Poughkeepsie
Year Established: 1974
Services Offered: Auto accidents, pedestrian accidents, criminal defense
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Petito & Petito has been labeled as “excellent advocates” and praised for “listening and explaining everything.” Clients appreciate their direct, candid approach and their focus on providing clear guidance while aggressively advocating for their interests. |
Rinaldi Law, for family-run services
Rinaldi Law is a local, family-run firm on Arlington Avenue in Poughkeepsie, specializing in both personal injury and tax law. The small team allows for highly personalized attention, with day-to-day communication often handled directly by daughter Alessandra. While pedestrian accidents are part of their practice, the firm tends to focus more on tax cases, which can lead to uneven client experiences. Those who value a close-knit, personalized approach may appreciate working with Rinaldi Law, though clients seeking dedicated pedestrian accident expertise might find the focus more limited.
Location: Poughkeepsie, NY
Year Established: 1986
Services Offered: Tax law, auto accidents, pedestrian accidents, auto accidents, wrongful death cases
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Rinaldi Law has been described as “family oriented” and “welcoming and understanding,” with Alessandra often praised as “excellent in communicating” with clients. At the same time, some reviews call the firm “rude, impatient, no compassion,” reflecting the limitations of a small, family-run team handling multiple case types. |
Rutberg Breslow Personal Injury Law, for statewide representation
Rutberg Breslow Personal Injury Law is known for aggressively pursuing compensation for injured New Yorkers. The firm focuses solely on personal injury, handling a wide range of cases from vehicle accidents and construction injuries to defective medical devices and nursing home neglect. While pedestrian accident cases are fewer, the firm’s broad approach reflects its willingness to tackle complex claims statewide. Reviews suggest clients appreciate their determination, though managing such a diverse practice with a small senior team can occasionally stretch resources.
Location: Poughkeepsie (with offices in the Catskills, Adirondacks, and Mohawk Valley)
Year Established: 1999
Services Offered: Nursing home neglect, defective medical devices, vehicle accidents, pedestrian accidents, construction injuries
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Rutberg Breslow Personal Injury Law is “professional, effective” and its attorneys are “kind, caring, knowledgeable.” Some clients report being “disheartened with the end result” or feeling the firm had a “used car salesman approach,” reflecting the challenges of managing many different types of personal injury cases. |
MidHudson Injury Law, for serious injuries
MidHudson Injury Law, also known as Schneider Law Offices, focuses on serious personal injury cases across New York. This includes the occasional pedestrian accidents, though the firm does not specifically list it as an area of practice on its website. With its main office in New Paltz and additional locations in Manhattan, Queens, White Plains, and Poughkeepsie, the firm brings regional reach to its clients. While the firm’s overall case success rate is lower than many peers, reviews highlight the team’s dedication and the strong rapport clients have with Bryan, suggesting that their lower outcomes may stem from taking on particularly complex or high-stakes cases.
Location: New Paltz, NY (with offices in Manhattan, Queens, White Plains, and Poughkeepsie)
Year Established: 1990s
Services Offered: Serious injury litigation, automobile accidents, animal attacks, wrongful death cases
| Summary of Online Reviews |
| Bryan Schneider is known for being “empathetic, thorough, and incredibly knowledgeable.” Clients highlight that he keeps his priorities first and is “pleasant to be around” while handling personal injury matters. |
+++
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose the right pedestrian accident lawyer for my case?
Look for attorneys with proven experience handling pedestrian cases locally, positive client reviews, and a track record of favorable outcomes. Consider whether you need a lawyer who specializes in pedestrian accidents or one with broader personal injury experience.
Do bigger firms mean better results for pedestrian accident cases?
Not necessarily. Bigger firms may have more resources and handle complex injury cases, while smaller or family-run firms can offer more personalized attention. The best fit depends on whether you prioritize specialization, accessibility, or individualized service.
Why do some highly rated attorneys have lower case success rates?
Some firms take on complex or high-stakes cases that can reduce overall success percentages, even if clients are satisfied with communication and service. A lower success rate doesn’t always indicate poor representation.
Should I consider a firm that doesn’t list pedestrian accidents as a primary practice area?
It can still be a good option. Attorneys with broad personal injury experience may be effective for serious or multi-faceted pedestrian claims. Ask about their past pedestrian cases to assess their expertise before deciding.
+++
This ranking is based on publicly available data and an independent analysis. It is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For more information on rpedestrian accident support in Poughkeepsie and Dutchess County, please read here.
